While watching Pirates of the Caribbean, most people see streams of action, humor and romance on the screen. What I saw was a group of smiling men in suits in an executive Disney office. And I’m not talking about the men who are smiling because their film broke the coveted $300 million mark, I’m talking about the ones who, some years ago, were smiling because they’d just written a script they knew was going to break the $300 million mark.

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl does everything just the way the “how to write a blockbuster script” book tells you to. The tight, frequent and intensive actions, the growing romance between two of the most attractive kids in the business – done up just enough to keep it moving without going overboard; and a primary, lovable, comic-relief character with punch lines and one-liners galore. Despite its unusually extended length for a Disney film, you can still taste all of the extra scenes and shots that have been shaven off to keep it tight and flowing. And you can hear the frequent revisions done to the script – make this scarier here – up the intensity here – say that punch line a little louder here – Pirates is as calculated a film as you can possible get. And yet, it really is good.

The final product is a story about the curse that lies upon a gang of evil pirates led by Captain Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush). The curse cannot be lifted until they have a certain gold medallion, carried by Elizabeth Swan (Keira Knightley). The pirates capture Elizabeth, but are followed by Will Turner (Orlando Bloom), who is in love with Elizabeth, and Captain Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp), who is helping Will so that he can get his ship back, the same ship that was taken from him by Barbossa.

Elizabeth and Will do their jobs well enough, which consists mostly of being cute while occasionally saving each others lives and Will conveniently practices fencing three hours a day so we can get some good swordfights in. But the show is really stolen by Depp, whose wobbly, seemingly drunken, Keith Richards-esque, pirate character is frequently pulling laughs through his carefully written one-liners and well performed facial reactions and body movements.

Though the actors are clearly having fun in their roles, so, it would seem, is director Gore Verbinski while playing with the trappings of the pirate world. Pirates does even better than Cutthroat Island at getting it all in, sometimes picking fun of the pirate conventions while building upon them at other times. Just as fun are the scenes that are set up to mirror visual elements from the Disneyland ride.

Pirates of the Caribbean turns out to be just as fun a ride. You can see right through it – but it works. It’s funny, it’s intense, and it’s entertaining. It may be all manufactured, but it’s manufactured right.

 
 
 

Year:

MPAA Rating: Running Time: Date Written:  
2003 PG-13 2:23 10/03  
film | music | books | links